GHSA-7rx3-28cr-v5wh Handlebars.js has a Prototype Method Access Control Gap via Missing __lookupSetter__ Blocklist Entry

Summary

The prototype method blocklist in lib/handlebars/internal/proto-access.js blocks constructor, __defineGetter__, __defineSetter__, and __lookupGetter__, but omits the symmetric __lookupSetter__. This omission is only exploitable when the non-default runtime option allowProtoMethodsByDefault: true is explicitly set — in that configuration __lookupSetter__ becomes accessible while its counterparts remain blocked, creating an inconsistent security boundary.

4.6.0 is the version that introduced protoAccessControl and the allowProtoMethodsByDefault runtime option.

Description

In lib/handlebars/internal/proto-access.js:

const methodWhiteList = Object.create(null);
methodWhiteList['constructor']      = false;
methodWhiteList['__defineGetter__'] = false;
methodWhiteList['__defineSetter__'] = false;
methodWhiteList['__lookupGetter__'] = false;
// __lookupSetter__ intentionally blocked in CVE-2021-23383,
// but omitted here — creating an asymmetric blocklist

All four legacy accessor helpers (__defineGetter__, __defineSetter__, __lookupGetter__, __lookupSetter__) were involved in the exploit chain addressed by CVE-2021-23383. Three of the four were explicitly blocked; __lookupSetter__ was left out.

When allowProtoMethodsByDefault: true is set, any prototype method not present in methodWhiteList is permitted by default. Because __lookupSetter__ is absent from the list, it passes the checkWhiteList check and is accessible in templates, while __lookupGetter__ (its sibling) is correctly denied.

Workarounds

• Do not set allowProtoMethodsByDefault: true. The default configuration is not affected.
• If allowProtoMethodsByDefault must be enabled, ensure templates do not reference __lookupSetter__ through untrusted input.